Ricardo Orellana became Chico State’s farm director in 2023 amidst a swell of disparaging remarks from people he would soon call colleagues. In August 2024, he signed a settlement with the university agreeing to “voluntarily resign,” waiving his ability to take legal action against the university or its employees.
The university also paid him nearly $61,000 — the equivalent of five months of his salary. This was a condition of his “voluntary resignation,” according to the settlement document obtained in October through a public records request.
Orellana, who has relocated, declined to speak with ChicoSol, saying, “my concern is a high possibility of retaliation against me. They already affected me severely.”
Orellana left Chico State only 15 months after he was hired, and is now a key figure in a lawsuit filed by a former dean who alleges a hostile work environment and discrimination.
Pushed out
Two people familiar with the matter said that interim dean of the College of Agriculture, David Hassenzahl, brought Orellana to a meeting where he was presented with two options: resign or be fired.
When asked about the meeting, Hassenzahl said that he couldn’t discuss personnel matters.
A subsequent public records request confirmed that there was no university investigation that led to the settlement.
The farm director is an administrative position, and is considered an at-will employee, allowing the university to terminate an employment contract at any time without a reason, unless it violates employment laws, such as racial discrimination.
His settlement waived his right to sue for anything that would violate employment laws. University spokesperson Andrew Staples said settlements are common. “It is also common for settlement agreements to include clauses that prohibit future legal action,” Staples said.
When Orellana signed the settlement agreement, he had a scheduled meeting with the former diversity officer for the university, Joseph Morales. Morales said that he did not know what Orellana wanted to talk about, but that Orellana “never made it to the meeting.”
Staples said the university disagrees with ChicoSol’s and the lawsuit’s portrayal of its actions, but declined to respond to questions about specific points of disagreement.
A key figure in Stock lawsuit
Orellana is key to the case of Patricia Stock, whose lawsuit is ongoing against the university and California State University system. The former dean of the Ag college alleges officials, such as President Steve Perez and Staff Human Resources Vice President Sheryl Woodward, violated policies by not reporting discrimination allegations made by Stock.
Stock was fired shortly after Orellana stepped into his role in 2023, and she alleges her appointment of Orellana led to racist remarks from some in the Ag college and members of the Butte County Farm Bureau.
Discovery documents in her legal process confirm remarks targeted at Orellana and Stock.

Within text messages that were made part of the lawsuit’s discovery phase, Organic Farm Manager Darby Heffner and Meats Lab Technician Haydn Clement call Orellana, who is native to El Salvador, a “foreigner.”
Clement texted: “Kasey [DeAtley] has it in the bag but there is one foreigner that knows how to play the game.”
Heffner replied: “Fucking foreigner … the dean is probably all about that.”
No one has faced disciplinary action since the release of the text exchanges. “While the language in those messages runs against our values as a University and expectations for professional conduct, we cannot comment on specific personnel matters,“ Staples said in an email to ChicoSol.
Several faculty ChicoSol spoke with said Orellana had an impressive resume and was “by far the best pick,” but some said after his contentious arrival, they were surprised he stayed.
Orellana studied in Hondorus, Chile and El Salvador. He received his doctorate in plant and soil science at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. He continued to garner international experience as he worked in Central and South America, Egypt and at Cornell University, before becoming the first person of color to become farm director at Chico State.
But his arrival came amid existing tension in the Ag college.
Emails and text messages previously reported in ChicoSol detail a behind-the-scenes campaign from some in the Ag college who wanted Ag professor Kasey DeAtley, a Farm Bureau member, to take the farm director position.
The outgoing farm director, Dave Daley, sent a message to a group chat where he talked about influencing donors in an effort to pressure Perez to fire Stock, according to court documents.
“Make sure Dustin [Bush] knows the farm director is the final straw …”, Daley said to Pat Andersen, a farm donor, in the group chat. Andersen sits on Superior Agriculture, a nonprofit advisory group to the college. Bush is the director of philanthropy for University Advancement while also being an associate director of development for the Ag college.
When a reporter approached Bush, he said he didn’t want to comment and that he didn’t want to hear the questions.
In another text to Andersen, Daley said: “He [Orellana] worries me. I don’t think he could be farm director, but I worry that he appeals to some of the faculty. A lot of diversity, equity, inclusion and justice in his presentation.”
When Stock appealed her termination, she wrote to administrators that the Butte County Farm Bureau, which is part of a statewide lobbyist group, tried pressuring her into hiring DeAtley.
Stock says she was also called to a Superior Ag meeting prior to Orellana’s selection, where she alleges racist and crude sentiments were expressed at the meeting, according to court documents.
One of the people at the meeting allegedly said: “This will not be forgotten,” and “this will not be forgiven” about her pick for farm director, according to court documents.
Stock sent a summary of the meeting and her concerns to Perez, and asked to meet with him. She alleges he never responded, according to court documents.
ChicoSol interviewed three people who attended the meeting, but none were able to verify Stock’s claims of overtly racist comments. However, the three in attendance said the meeting was shocking in terms of the hostility aimed at Stock and Orellana.
Shortly after, Stock’s complaint letter alleges: “administrators then encouraged Dr. Stock to resign, forfeiting her right to retreat to a faculty position, in exchange for permission to announce her ‘resignation’ and send a message passing the decision off as her own.”
Orellana settles in at the farm
When Stock was fired, Orellana was still settling into the farm. During his time there he continued to face a contentious work culture, according to Ag faculty and staff who spoke to ChicoSol.

There was a dispute at the farm and a contentious April 2024 meeting occurred between Orellana and some staff. Some attendees who spoke to ChicoSol about the meeting said it “got out of hand” and Orellana tried to deescalate.
“Lines got crossed and the meeting just got way out of hand — people talking over people, Ricardo [Orellana] trying to deescalate and rephrase what he said, and I think there was miscommunication there,” said Hunter Ortiz, a former staffer at the farm.
Orellana sent an email on April 26, 2024 to Hassenzahl and his associate dean about the meeting, saying that there were several moments of “micro-aggression” against Orellana and some students. It’s unclear if there was action taken following that email.
Hassenzahl said that he was aware of the meeting, and if there were any Title IX violations then he would have reported it. Patton said he couldn’t comment on personnel matters.
It is also unclear how many times, if any, Orellana complained about discrimination to administrators. California State University refused to produce documents related to complaints, citing the lawsuit and stating that the interest in preserving privacy outweighed the interest in disclosing them to the public. However, Mayling Nicolas, a paralegal supervisor in the CSU’s Office of General Counsel, said the system would reconsider the public records request after Stock’s lawsuit concluded.
After Stock was fired, Dean of the College of Natural Sciences David Hassenzahl became interim dean of the Ag college. He was the interim dean during the time Orellana signed the settlement.
“He’s very qualified and doing a great job, and comes with a lot of experience in ag extension, which is how universities share their agricultural knowledge with the community,” Hassenzahl previously told ChicoSol when Orellana was first hired. “He’s very experienced in working with communities and raising a variety of crops.”
After Orellana left in August 2024, Hassenzahl’s associate dean, Kevin Patton, became farm director. Patton was originally a professor in the kinesiology department and grew up on an almond farm.
His father, Wes Patton, was a professor in the Ag college and had been professor for several faculty, staff and Farm Bureau members who were participating in the text messages produced through Stock’s discovery process. He continues to be a substantial donor to the Ag college, and the sheep unit was named after him. Patton’s brother, Matt, was one of the people Daley attempted to use in the pressure campaign to lobby for Stock’s termination.
Ag staff and faculty said Patton’s tenure as interim farm director and dean of the Ag college has brought positive change. In comments to ChicoSol, they said he was working hard on behalf of students and trying to build bridges in a college that people have described as divided.
Seeking new farm director
The university is now searching for a new farm director.
According to people familiar with the matter who prefer to remain unnamed for fear of retribution, there are four candidates. One of those candidates, Patrick Doyle, was associate dean of the Ag college from 2018-2023, according to his LinkedIn account. He has been the department head of Animal Sciences at the Colorado State University since.
Unlike the contentious search process in 2023, the Farm Bureau and Superior Ag are not involved with this search, Staples confirmed.
Staples also confirmed that Heffner and Clement were not on the 10-member search committee for the new director. But Darby Heffner’s husband, Travis, is on the search committee.
Sources in the Ag college said the university seems to have made operational changes from the last search process that resulted in two people of color who voiced discrimination concerns to choose between being fired or resigning.
Chris Hutton is a contributing reporter to ChicoSol.

