Police use of deadly force? Here’s one solution. Writer to cops: 'Break the blue wall of silence'

by George Gold
guest commentary

From The Sacramento Bee’s front page in 1967: “Two dozen armed Negroes entered the state Capitol at noon today and made their way to the back of the Assembly Chamber before they were disarmed and marched away by the state police.”

photo by Mark Comfort courtesy of Wikipedia
In May 1967, Black Panther members protesting police brutality and a new law marched on the State Capitol.

This happened in the midst of the ‘power to the people’ campaign organized to shine a light on police brutality in the Black community. After more than 50 years, has anything changed?

In Los Angeles, 1991, Rodney King was brutally beaten by cops as the whole country watched; somehow he survived.

Unfortunately, there have been thousands more killed unnecessarily at the hands of our police just over the last decade. Police departments across the country are all too often participating in behavior that shocks the conscience… and we all watch.

Over this last decade, there has been an ever-escalating trend in the militarization of our police departments, and along with this militarization has come an attitude of ‘us versus them’ as the default police mindset. Cops see themselves as warriors, not guardians. Is it any wonder we go from one killing to the next? These attitudes of us-versus-them and warrior-versus-guardian will never lead to peaceful community policing.

screenshot from CNN courtesy of Wikipedia
In March 1991, Rodney King was beaten by police, sparking riots.

Based on the Washington Post Fatal Force database, in 2019, across the United States, 1,004 people were shot and killed by police. In this same year more than 228 police officers committed suicide. That’s over 1,200 lives lost unnecessarily.

What’s wrong with this picture? Clearly, not only are our police killing us; the stress of the job is too often too much to handle and our cops are killing themselves in increasing numbers. Wouldn’t it be better to have mentally healthy cops on the beat?

Anyone who has played a video game of shoot’em up can become complacent when it comes to gun violence. But what really shocks the conscience, in real life, is watching the police shooter or police leader in violence do their fatal deeds in full view of their fellow officers.

Last month, in Minnesota, George Floyd was murdered, on camera. Anyone who has watched one of the countless cop shows on television that show explicit violence until we’re numb is not surprised by what they saw in the film of Floyd’s murder. It’s easy to think, “oh, poor fellow, get off him and get him up.” But the more you watch the more you can’t help but think, ‘Why doesn’t someone stop this?’

photo by George Gold
Women protest the killing of George Floyd at a Sunday march in Oroville organized to call for police reform.

Oh wait, not just someone. Why not one of the other three cops standing there watching? Three human beings, three cops, with all sorts of training on how to handle confrontations of all kinds — and not one of them did anything to stop their fellow officer from killing yet another helpless human being.

These days, 99% of the time, cops are not on patrol alone. They are usually part of a pair, and almost immediately after an officer-needs-assistance call, they will be joined by a half dozen or more additional officers at the scene.

We can have all the discussions we want, we can even riot to express our outrage, but until cops on the beat police each other, until the blue code of silence is broken, these police killings will not end.

Today, our society seems hell bent on heroism. We have a media fascination and propagation of calling out to identify a hero every other minute. A doctor, a nurse, a firefighter, and very often a police officer is at the head of the hero queue. The real hero cops? They are the ones who step in front of their fellow officers and tell them, “Stop, stop it right now.”

Or how about that cop (alone) in Georgia who traveled out to a disturbing the peace call in a residential neighborhood? Upon arrival he found several Black teenagers playing basketball in the street and, yes, some loud music was playing. Did he call for backup? No. Was he aggressive in talking to the teenagers? No. Did he chat with them politely and quietly? Yes. Did he ask for the basketball and join the game? Yes.

That’s what community policing is all about.

I don’t think that George Floyd got this sort of treatment. So where were these “nice” cops while George Floyd was being murdered?

When cops are in training in their respective police academies, when they graduate, do they think, “Ahh, finally, I get to bust some heads”? No, I don’t think so. I think every single young cop out there starts out with an honest desire to “protect and serve.”

In my hometown of Chico, Calif., in October 2018, half a dozen police officers surrounded an 8-year-old boy, handcuffed him and despite pleas from passersby, refused to take off his handcuffs as he sat on the sidewalk, his hands cuffed behind him, the child crying uncontrollably.

Then, in July 2019, half a dozen police officers surrounded and tackled to the ground and handcuffed an 11-year-old girl during a so-called welfare check. Fortunately, these incidents did not result in the same sort of horrific outcomes the likes of which we saw in the Chico police killings of Tyler Rushing and Desmond Phillips.

De-escalation training, crisis intervention training and the application of these techniques in the field, and, civilian oversight of the police are imperative. But during all of the events just described, regardless of training, not one cop stood between these victims and their fellow cops’ abuse of power.

We can demonstrate all we want, and yes we might even riot to vent our anger, but nothing will change until real hero cops break the blue code of silence and step between we the public and their fellow officers’ abuse of power. This is the only solution to ending police violence. This is the moral imperative police officers must take to heart and must act upon.

George Gold is a computer systems engineer, a webmaster and a world traveler who is active in local police reform efforts.

3 thoughts on “Police use of deadly force? Here’s one solution. Writer to cops: 'Break the blue wall of silence'

  1. George; I often want to say or write something about something but I don’t really know how – YOU KNOW HOW!!

  2. Excellent article George, I have some additional suggestions to curtail the unnecessary use of lethal force:
    -Fire the “higher-ups” who allow rogue cops to roam the streets with firearms. Fire the sergeants, lieutenants, commanders, deputy chiefs, and administrators. Imagine the quick change in the violent and quick use of lethal force now being taught to cops if the “higher-ups” suffered the consequences of rogue cops who violate the civil rights of citizens and commit criminal acts against citizens. The Minneapolis cop with the heavy knee on the neck of George Floyd had EIGHTEEN civilian complaints made against him. He should never have been allowed to be a cop. Mr. Floyd and his family paid a high price for the practice of cops covering for each other behind the blue wall of silence.
    -FIRE rogue cops and hire good cops.

  3. Butte County Sheriff’s had an officer that they would not re-hire due to too many excessive use of force complaints. So Chico PD hired him.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *